I think I see what happened ...I selected the S&P index for a 3 year comparson. So the chart was recalibrated to 0% at the date that S&P took over management of the index. Sorry folks. How about this one...MET comes out on top.
Attachment 8231
Printable View
I think I see what happened ...I selected the S&P index for a 3 year comparson. So the chart was recalibrated to 0% at the date that S&P took over management of the index. Sorry folks. How about this one...MET comes out on top.
Attachment 8231
Thanks BJ. I see that your chart stops at 1 August 2016. Is it possible to show what it looks like up to today??
Sharesight tells me 10 K invested into each of the three returned all up profit incl dividends from 14/08/2014 -14/08/2016 the following profit.
SUM $ 8358.84 35.44 % PA
MET $ 3825.20 17.56 % PA
RYM $ 2546.46 12 % PA
Fair call Roger but you are rewriting history a bit .Remember your SUM love affair , then you were jilted by Norah and you got a bit upset. Declared RYM best of breed ,then wrote RYM off saying FV was $ 6.50 and thats where you would buy it . Then fell in love with both of them again, maybe SUM more so ...More flip flops than David Cunliffe .......
Overall great sector to be involved with , I still rate RYM best of breed , great we all making more than the bank pays .Happy that you made the most of the opportunity cost .
LOL. Was just thinking the same thing, stoploss. In fact, I recall having quite a few debates with Roger over the last couple of years where I declared SUM to be the best and he instead backed RYM. Knew he'd come to his senses eventually, though :)
No Problems...here is a 3 year and a 3 month comparison.
Attachment 8232
Attachment 8233
awesome, thanks BJ
Bjauck - so SUM is the best since 18/8/2013?
Surely the comparisons need to be done at the same stages of the business? And how can we really compare them with such a huge difference in start times? RYM would have had more risk as they were doing the R&D in the sector?